AfterSell prices its plans on your store’s total monthly orders and sells cart and post-purchase offers on separate plans. So its bill can climb in a month when upsells don’t. Black Friday-Cyber Monday shows how fast that happens: Shopify merchants’ sales rose 27% over BFCM 2025, and more than 94,900 merchants had their best sales day ever, according to Shopify’s BFCM 2025 results.
As of October 25, 2026, AfterSell’s Shopify App Store listing says the app isn’t currently available, so new stores can’t install it.
I compared five alternatives, OneClickUpsell (OCU), ReConvert (now Upsell.com), Rebuy, Wiser and Selleasy, on what the bill follows, which placements share one plan and how A/B testing is sold. Every price comes from the vendor’s own pricing page, listing or help docs.
AfterSell Alternatives Worth Considering
Most of these apps bill on store orders in some form. Only OneClickUpsell bills on upsell revenue alone, and ReConvert counts whichever of the two puts you in a higher tier (a bit tricky story).
Scroll sideways for more →
| App | Billed on | Starts at | Placements | A/B testing | Open to new installs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OneClickUpsellOur app | Upsell revenue | $9.95/mo after a 30-day trial | Product page, pop-up, cart drawer, checkout (Plus), post-purchase, thank-you page | Every placement, every plan | Available |
| AfterSell | Total store orders | $34.99/mo (Post-Purchase) | Post-purchase, thank-you page, checkout (Plus); cart and product page on Pre-Purchase | Carts and offers | Unavailable |
| ReConvert (Upsell.com) | Store orders or upsell revenue, whichever is higher | Free up to 50 orders; $9.99/mo | Product page, cart, cart drawer, checkout (Plus), post-purchase, thank-you page | Every plan | Available |
| Rebuy | Total store orders, per package | $25/mo per package | Cart and checkout/post-purchase are separate packages | Separate package | Unavailable |
| Wiser | Total store orders | Free up to 50 orders; $9/mo | Home, product page, cart drawer, checkout, post-purchase, thank-you page | Under analytics | Available |
| Selleasy | Free under 50 orders, then a flat monthly fee | Free up to 50 orders; $15/mo | Product page, cart, post-purchase; Plus checkout on Pro | Not listed | Unavailable |
What Is AfterSell, And Why Do Merchants Switch?
AfterSell is a Shopify upsell app that Rokt agreed to acquire in January 2024, according to Digital Commerce 360. It runs one-click post-purchase offers, thank-you page offers and, on Shopify Plus, checkout upsells, and it now includes a cart drawer. The reasons merchants give for leaving mostly come back to billing and packaging.
The bill follows store orders
Orders from ads, email and returning customers all count toward the tier. In an April 2026 App Store review, one merchant said they were charged $149.99 after their store grew, while AfterSell brought in less than in the period before: “I’m paying more for worse performance.”
Cart and post-purchase offers sit on different plans
Post-Purchase covers post-purchase, thank-you page and Plus checkout offers. Cart and product page offers are on Pre-Purchase. Running both takes Complete, from $79.99 a month.
Post-purchase-only funnels leave revenue behind
In the same Zipify audit, stores with two or more placements earned 2.5x the upsell revenue of post-purchase-only stores, and stores with three or more earned 3.6x. Pre-purchase placements converted 57% better than post-purchase ones.
How I Chose These Apps
I started with the apps merchants most often compare with AfterSell: Shopify apps that run one-click post-purchase offers plus at least one placement before checkout. Then I went through each one’s pricing page, App Store listing and help docs, and compared:
- Billing basis. Store orders, upsell revenue, or packages.
- Placements per plan. Which offers share one plan and which cost extra.
- Testing and offer logic. How A/B tests are sold and how products are picked.
1. OneClickUpsell — Every Placement on One Plan, Billed on Upsell Revenue
OneClickUpsell (OCU) by Zipify runs upsells from the product page to the thank-you page in one app. It’s used by 50,000+ Shopify stores and has tracked $1.5B+ in upsell revenue. Only revenue from accepted OCU offers counts toward the bill, so a spike in regular orders doesn’t move it.
Key features
- Product page offers, pre-purchase pop-ups and a Slide Cart Drawer that has helped merchants grow AOV by 20%;
- One-click post-purchase upsells and downsells, thank-you page offers, and in-checkout offers on Shopify Plus;
- A/B split testing at every placement, on every plan;
- AI Personalized Funnels, plus an AI Assistant that reads your store data and recommends what to fix next (it never changes anything on its own);
- PostProfit, which places brand-safe ads on the thank-you page and pays out via PayPal to offset the bill.
Start your 30-day free trial of OneClickUpsell on the Shopify App Store
Pricing
A 30-day free trial, then from $9.95 a month for up to $200 in upsell revenue, rising by tier to a $999 cap. Every tier includes every feature, and development stores are free.
Pros
- Busy order months don’t raise the bill
- All six placements from the $9.95 tier
- Easy to navigate (TORRAIN)
- Support that goes above and beyond (Amy Romeu)
Cons
- In-checkout offers need Shopify Plus, a Shopify rule for every app
- Advanced features work best with regular testing
2. ReConvert (Upsell.com) — Every Feature on Every Plan, Billed on Orders or Upsell Revenue
ReConvert, now branded Upsell.com, has been on the Shopify App Store since September 2018. It runs offers from the product page to the thank-you page, including one-click post-purchase funnels. Its listing names an easy switch from AfterSell, and the app also runs on Wix.
Key features
- Product page, cart page, cart drawer and thank-you page offers, plus checkout upsells on Shopify Plus;
- One-click post-purchase funnels;
- Frequently bought together, bundles, quantity breaks and free gifts;
- AI recommendations, custom rules and a Flow Builder;
- A/B testing on every plan, the Free plan included.
Pricing
Free up to 50 orders or $50 in upsell revenue a month. Paid tiers run $9.99 (up to 100), $19.99 (200), $39.99 (500), $79.99 (1,000) and $149.99 (2,000), each set by store orders or upsell revenue, whichever is higher (Upsell.com pricing). Paid plans have a 14-day trial.
Pros
- $0 plan up to 50 orders or $50 in upsell revenue
- The same app works on Wix
- A/B tests made it easy to try different strategies (Crumble Cookware)
- Clear, detailed setup help from support (Donner Music)
Cons
- Store orders set the tier even when upsells earn little (TEKVIYON)
- The Bundle widget doesn’t support digital products (Incredible Bite Shop)
- Setup can be hard to follow (Gerard Cosmetics)
- Checkout offers need Shopify Plus (Helsekostgiganten)
3. Rebuy — Personalization Sold as Four Packages
Rebuy is a personalization platform that covers search, cart, checkout and post-purchase. It’s sold as four packages, each priced on your store’s total monthly orders, online and in person. Rebuy Monetize, powered by Fluent, adds partner offers to the thank-you page at no charge.
Key features
- Smart Cart, a slide-out cart with a tiered progress bar and switch-to-subscription;
- AI widgets such as Customer Also Bought and Frequently Bought Together;
- Up to 40 post-purchase flows, plus checkout extensions on Shopify Plus;
- A/B tests with up to nine variations in the Flows & A/B Testing package;
- Smart Search and integrations with Klaviyo, Recharge and others.
Pricing
Base prices cover up to 500 orders a month: Checkout & Post-Purchase $25, Search & Collections $35, Flows & A/B Testing $35 and Cart & Merchandising $45 (Rebuy pricing). Bundles save 10–30%, with a 14-day trial. At 5,000 orders, cart plus checkout costs $585 a month.
Pros
- Search, cart and checkout from one vendor
- Free thank-you page partner offers with Monetize
- A five-figure revenue lift from Smart Cart, checkout and post-purchase offers (Black Rifle Coffee Company)
- Cart goals reached without major dev work (Tubby Todd Bath Co.)
Cons
- Costs add up as you stack packages and orders grow (Goodevas)
- Smart Cart clashed with other discount apps (Catastrophic Industries)
- Live chat couldn’t help build a post-purchase offer (Forest Super Foods)
4. Wiser — AI Recommendation Widgets Across the Store
Wiser AI – Upsell & Cross Sell, from Expert Village Media Technologies, has been on the Shopify App Store since April 2017. It centers on AI recommendation widgets, from the homepage to post-purchase. It also includes IntelliSearch, an AI search and filter tool with its own analytics.
Key features
- Recommendation widgets on the homepage, product pages, cart and checkout;
- A Slide Cart Drawer with a rewards bar;
- Post-purchase, thank-you and order status page upsells;
- AI frequently-bought-together bundles, Shop the Look and Pair It With;
- A/B testing under analytics, with reports every two weeks.
Pricing
Free up to 50 orders a month, then $9 (51–100 orders), $19 (101–300) and $49 (301–500), with a 14-day trial. Every plan has the same features.
Pros
- $0 plan up to 50 orders a month
- Recommendation widgets and AI search in one install
- The team customized widgets to match the store’s design (Amber Lollipop)
- Smarter recommendations lifted sales (Hemani Herbals)
Cons
- Every store order counts toward the plan, not just recommended sales (Postmoda)
- The free plan still asks you to approve a monthly charge (Hamilton & Co)
- Some listed features cost extra (Wittworkshop)
5. Selleasy — Product Page Add-Ons at a Flat Price Past 50 Orders
Selleasy by Logbase is a low-cost app for product page add-ons, bundles and one-click post-purchase offers. On October 13, 2026, Logbase said in an incident statement that a planned cyber-attack injected a script into some stores, which redirected shoppers to a phishing page, and Roman Zipp’s write-up of the Shopify checkout hijack lists Selleasy among several affected apps. Logbase says it found no backend data breach and fixed the cause, but the listing was still closed to new installs on October 25, 2026.
Key features
- Frequently bought together bundles and add-ons on the product page;
- Cart pop-up add-ons, plus upsell and downsell funnels;
- One-click post-purchase offers on every Shopify plan;
- Related products from Shopify AI and add-ons from Selleasy’s own AI;
- Support over chat, email and Zoom.
Pricing
Selleasy is free while your store stays under 50 orders a month. Once you pass that, you choose a flat monthly plan: Starter for $15, Pro for $49 (adds checkout upsells for Shopify Plus stores) or Max for $99 (adds a rules engine). Every paid plan comes with a 30-day free trial, and Selleasy takes no share of your upsell revenue.
Pros
- One flat fee once you pass 50 orders
- Setup calls are easy to book (Wooof.co.uk)
- £20k+ in upsells in under a year (WBC)
- Costs far less than pricier upsell apps (Jesusdoll.com)
Cons
- Shoppers could add more than one free gift (Wood Workers Workshop)
- Bundle prices didn’t update when shoppers changed size (The Jaipur Wala)
- Installing pushed one store into a trial instead of the free plan (Shark Sports)
Which AfterSell Alternative Should You Choose?
Start from the problem that made you look for an alternative.
- If your bill jumps in busy months: Pick an app whose bill ignores regular orders. OneClickUpsell is the only app here billed on upsell revenue alone. ReConvert counts upsell revenue too, but store orders set the tier when they’re higher.
- If you’re under 50 orders a month: ReConvert, Wiser and Selleasy all have free plans at that size. OCU starts at $9.95 after its 30-day trial, with every placement included.
- If you want every placement on one plan: OCU and ReConvert both put product page, cart, post-purchase and thank-you page offers on every plan. On AfterSell and Rebuy, cart and post-purchase offers are sold separately.
- If you also sell on Wix: Upsell.com (ReConvert) is the only app here with a Wix version.
- If you’re on Shopify Plus: Every app here needs Plus for in-checkout offers. OCU includes them on every tier, and Zipify Plus has Zipify’s team build and test your funnels for a flat monthly fee. Most brands that join see around 30x ROI, and Cheech & Chong made $90,000+ in 7 weeks after moving from Rebuy.
For a head-to-head breakdown, see OneClickUpsell vs. AfterSell
The Bottom Line
For most Shopify stores leaving AfterSell, I recommend OneClickUpsell. It puts every placement on one plan from $9.95 a month, and its bill follows the upsell revenue it brings in, so a busy month of regular orders won’t move it.
FAQs
What is the best AfterSell alternative?
For most Shopify stores, OneClickUpsell. It covers every placement on one plan from $9.95 a month and bills on upsell revenue, not store orders. Stores under 50 orders a month can start free on ReConvert, Wiser or Selleasy.
Is AfterSell available on the Shopify App Store?
Not for new installs. As of October 25, 2026, its listing says the app isn’t currently available on the Shopify App Store. Stores that already run it can contact Rokt for support.
How much does AfterSell cost?
Post-Purchase starts at $34.99 a month, Pre-Purchase at $59.99 and Complete at $79.99, plus 5, 3 or 7 cents per order above the included orders. The plans are capped at $999.99, $599.99 and $1,359.99 a month.
What’s the difference between Rebuy and AfterSell?
They’re built for different jobs. Rebuy is a personalization platform sold as four packages, covering search, cart, checkout and post-purchase. AfterSell centers on post-purchase and thank-you page offers, with its cart on a separate plan. Both bill on total store orders, so compare them at your busiest month’s order count.
